TradingCritique

Select Your Brokers to Compare

Firstrade vs TD Direct Investing : Fees, Safety & Trading Conditions Compared (2026)

Broker Name

Firstrade

Firstrade

VS
TD Direct Investing

TD Direct Investing

Icon

Broker Overview

Broker Type (e.g., Market Maker, ECN/STP)

STP broker

None

Years of Existence / Established Year

1985

1984

Customer Base / Number of Accounts

1Million

17 M


Icon

Regulation & Security

Regulations (governing bodies)

FINRA, SEC

CIPF, CIRO

Awards Won (count for the last 2 years)

Best Online Brokers, Best for Options Traders award.

No major awards listed

Security Measures

SIPC

CIPF

SSL Encryption / 2FA

Yes

Yes

Segregated Funds

Yes

Yes

Negative Balance Protection

No

Yes


Icon

Trading Instruments/Products Offered

Assets Types / Trading Instruments (total count and breakdown)

2200+ ETFs including CDs, Treasury bills, Notets and bonds, Primary market CDs, Zeros and strips and more

Fixed income investments, GICs

Currency Pairs

No

No

Commodities

No

No

Indices

Yes- Through ETFs

No

Cryptocurrencies

Yes- Through ETFs

Yes

CFDs

No

No

ETFs

Yes

Yes

Stocks

Yes

Yes

Options

Yes

Yes

Futures

No

No

Bonds

Yes

Yes

Mutual Funds

Yes

Yes

Fractional Shares

Yes

No

Exchange Traded Notes (ETNs)

Yes

No

Precious Metals

No

Yes

Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs)

Yes

No

Equities

No

Yes


Icon

Trading Platforms & Technology

Trading Platform Availability

Yes

Yes

MT4

No

No

MT5

Yes

No

cTrader

No

No

Social Trading

No

No

Copy Trading

No

No

Other Trading Platforms (proprietary, etc.)

Firstrade platform

TD app, web trader, Advanced dashboard, TD active trader

Platform Compatibility (Windows, Mac, iOS, Android)

Yes

Yes


Icon

Account Types & Conditions

Account Types (Retail, Pro, VIP, etc.)

Brokerage account- Individual, Joint, Custodial, Retirement- Retirement (Traditional IRA, Roth IRA, SEP IRA), Corporate, Trust, International, Education Planning, Business Planning

Margin account, cash trading account, TFSA, RSP, RESP, RIF, LIRA, LIF, RDSP

Demo Account (Yes/No)

No

No

Islamic Accounts (Yes/No)

No

No

Minimum Deposit

$0

$0

Leverage Available

No

No

Trade Limit (maximum per trade)

Depends on asset class

Depends on asset types

Commission (per account type)

$0

NA

Best Suited For (e.g., beginners, experienced traders)

Both beginners and experienced traders

Beginners and experienced traders


Icon

Deposit & Withdrawal Options

Deposit Methods

Wire Fund Transfer, Check deposit, Asset transfer, ACH electronic transfer

Direct bank account, Check

Withdrawal Methods

Wire Fund Transfer, Check Deposit, Asset transfer, ACH electronic transfer, Withdrawal of sales proceed

SWIP, Wire payment

Other E-Wallets Supported

No

No


Icon

Tools & Educational Resources

Economic Calendar

Yes

Yes

Tools & Educational Resources (tutorials, webinars, market news, etc.)

Education Center, Investment Education Videos, Option Guide, Margin Guide, Webinars, Tax center, Blogs, Upcoming IPOs

Learning Centre - Investing Education, Market Insights and Analysis, Webinars, Investing Guides, Video Tutorials, TD Direct Investing Community Forum


Icon

Fees & Commissions

Trading-Related Fees

Commission for stocks, ETFs, Options, Mutual funds- $0, Fixed income- Treasury Bills, Notes & Bonds, Municipal Bonds, Agency Bonds, Secondary Market CDs, Zeros & Strips- Net yield basis, Primary Market CDs- $30, Broker-Assisted Stock & Options Trades- $19.95 (+$0.50/Contract)

Commission -mutual funds- $0 , IPOs, Equities- $7.00- $9.99, Stock - $3- $43, Bonds- $40 + $1.50/1,000

Spread (typical, fixed, variable)

Typical

NA

Per Lot Fees

NA

NA

Options Contract Fees

$0

$9.99 + $1.25 per contract

Futures Contract Fees

NA

NA

Markup Fees on Spread

NA

NA

Guaranteed Stop Loss Fees

NA

NA

Maximum Leverage

No

No


Icon

Non-Trading Fees

Dormant Fees

$0

NA

Subscription Fees (for premium features, data feeds)

NA

NA

Advisory Fees

0.20-0.30%

NA

Swap Fees (Overnight Financing)

NA

NA

Statement or Document Fee

$2-$5

$2-$5

Account Opening Fee

$0

Applicable, Depends on account types

Account Maintenance Fee

$0

$25 per quarter

Deposit Fee

$0

$17.50 U.S

Currency Conversion Fee

3%

2.50%

Withdrawal Fee

$25-$75

$30-$100


Icon

Bonuses, Promotions & Benefits

Bonuses, Promotions, and Referrals

Yes

Yes

Customer Benefits (e.g., Retirement Plan)

Yes

Yes


Icon

Trading Hours

Trading Hours (for each asset class if applicable)

Pre-Market: 8:00 AM to 9:30 AM ET Regular Market: 9:30 AM to 4:00 PM ET After-Hours: 4:05 PM to 8:00 PM ET

Pre-market trading hours (8 a.m. to 9:30 a.m. ET) and after-hours trading (4 p.m. to 8 p.m. ET)


Icon

Customer Support

Support Hours (e.g., 24/7, weekdays only)

Monday - Friday,10am - 4pm ET

Monday to Friday, 7 am to 10 pm ET

Customer Support Methods (phone, email, live chat)

Phone: U.S. Toll Free: 1-800-869-8800, Outside the US: 1-718-961-6600, E-mail, FAQ, Fax: 1-718-961-3919

Phone: 1-800-465-5463, , Book an appointment

Support Languages

3

4


Icon

Additional Information

Headquarters Location

30-50 Whitestone Expwy. Ste. A301 Flushing, NY 11354

66 Wellington Street West, Toronto, ON M5K 1A2

Complaints (for crypto brokers)

No

No


At TradingCritique, we don't just list brokers. We test, compare, and simplify your decision-making. Whether you're a beginner or a pro, our data-driven comparisons are built to match your trading style and region. Learn how we Evaluate a broker.
If minimizing trading costs is your top priority, Firstrade might be more attractive due to its lower commissions. Meanwhile, TD Direct Investing justifies its moderate fees with more robust tools and professional-grade features.
Creating an account with Firstrade is generally faster and more user-friendly, often taking just a few minutes, while TD Direct Investing requires more detailed steps and identity verification, which may suit more cautious investors.
If you're looking for platform speed and ease of execution, Firstrade delivers a smooth experience. TD Direct Investing, however, is tailored toward traders who want deeper analysis tools and portfolio insights.
Firstrade caters to serious traders who value advanced features, whereas TD Direct Investing appeals to beginners due to its user-friendly platform.