Broker reviews built on Regulation, not sponsorship.

We score every broker on a 50-point system where regulation carries 40% of the rating. No broker can pay to rank higher.

Untitled design 4
FCA Regulations

What TradingCritique is

TradingCritique is an independent broker review site. We evaluate brokers using a transparent 50-point scoring system, verify claims against regulator registers and official disclosures, and publish the results so you can make informed decisions.

Broker Reviews & Ratings

Every broker scored across regulation, fees, security, platform, and support. Our TC Rating tells you exactly where a broker is strong and where it falls short.

Broker Reviews & Ratings

Every broker scored across regulation, fees, security, platform, and support. Our TC Rating tells you exactly where a broker is strong and where it falls short.

Smart Broker Finder

Answer a few questions about your trading needs country, assets, budget and get matched with brokers that fit. No AI hype, just practical filtering.

Smart Broker Finder

Answer a few questions about your trading needs country, assets, budget and get matched with brokers that fit. No AI hype, just practical filtering.

Comparison & Analysis Tools

Compare any two brokers side-by-side across 1,831 comparison pages. Fees, regulation, platforms, and features all in one view.

Comparison & Analysis Tools

Compare any two brokers side-by-side across 1,831 comparison pages. Fees, regulation, platforms, and features all in one view.

NEW - TC Rating Showcase

TC Rating Criteria

How we score brokers - 50 points across 6 pillars

Each broker is evaluated on six weighted pillars. Bar width below shows how many points each pillar contributes to the total.

Regulation 20 points · 40% of score

Tier 1 licences (FCA, SEC, ASIC, BaFin), client fund segregation, compensation schemes

Trading costs 8 points · 16% of score

Spreads, commissions, swap rates, deposit and withdrawal fees

Security 7 points · 14% of score

Negative balance protection, 2FA, encryption, audit history

Product range 6 points · 12% of score

Forex, CFDs, stocks, ETFs, crypto, commodities, indices

Platform & execution 6 points · 12% of score

MT4, MT5, proprietary platforms, mobile, execution speed, slippage

Support & education 3 points · 6% of score

24/7 channels, response time, learning resources, demo accounts

Read Our Rating Criteria

TC Rated Brokers

Brokers we have scored

Every score below uses the 50-point method above. Each row shows where the points came from and the biggest deduction we found.

  • IG

    UK · FCA TC VALIDATED

    Biggest deduction: No insurance cover for offshore clients

    9.00/10
    45.00 / 50Review →

  • Tickmill

    UK · FCA TC VALIDATED

    Biggest deduction: FSCS limit misstated as £120,000

    8.25/10
    41.25 / 50Review →

  • Trading.com US

    USA · CFTC / NFA TC VALIDATED

    Biggest deduction: Settled $50,000 NFA fine in 2024

    8.47/10
    42.35 / 50Review →

  • XTB

    UK · FCA TC VALIDATED

    Biggest deduction: PLN 20 million KNF fine, upheld 2026

    8.85/10
    44.25 / 50Review →
  • Regulation
  • Trading costs
  • Security
  • Product range
  • Platform & execution
  • Support & education
Listed A to Z, not ranked · Scores checked: September 2026Full methodology →

Why Traders Trust TradingCritique

How our recommendations stay independent

12085814 20944299 1

Global Regulator Verification 

Explore brokers approved in your country with local regulations.

Data, Not Promotions 

No broker can pay to rank higher or influence our TC Rating.

49639860 9276417
4530296 19283

50-Point Evaluation Framework

We evaluate every broker across regulation, fees, security, product range, platform quality, and support. Regulation carries 40%  always.

Offshore Brokers Reviewed, Not Recommended

We review offshore-regulated brokers so you understand the risks. But our recommendations prioritize Tier 1 and Tier 2 regulated platforms where your money has real protection.

FCA regulation

Platforms We Track

Real brokers monitored across regulation, fees, and access

300+

trading platforms & brokers analyzed

40+

global regulators monitored

USED BY 1000+

traders every month worldwide

View All Resources